Simon Says

Bringing clarity to the inner workings of our legal system

COVID-19 and Elder-assisted hearings

Parole Board of Canada hearings have generally moved to WebEx, which has created some challenges. For example, Elder-assisted hearings may not be available for Indigenous prisoners.

In Elder-assisted hearings, those involved traditionally sit in a circle and an Elder is present to perform cultural protocols and spiritual ceremonies.

Elders can provide the Board members with information about the culture and tradition of the prisoner’s Indigenous community (or about Indigenous culture and traditions more generally). Elders are not involved in the decision-making, but they can advise the Board members regarding cultural and spiritual factors during the deliberation stage.

Since the COVID-19 pandemic began, Indigenous prisoners have not always had the option to have Elder-assisted hearings. This is unfortunate, as it may deprive the Board of important information about the Indigenous prisoners who come before them. Given the overrepresentation of Indigenous prisoners and the systemic factors that have contributed to this problem, the unavailability of Elder-assisted hearings is disappointing.

Even if an Elder-assisted hearing is not available, then it may still be possible for an Elder to attend as an observer. Such a request should be made well in advance of the hearing. However, the Elder would be there as an observer, and it remains at the discretion what role the Elder can have if there as simply an observer.

Past performance is not indicative of future results, and outcomes will vary according to the facts of individual cases. This site is intended for information purposes only. None of the information on this site should be considered “legal advice.” Information on this website (including blog posts and answers to frequently asked questions) is the opinion of the author only and is not warrantied or guaranteed to be an exhaustive, definitive, or accurate statement of the law. The proper interpretation and application of the law must always be done on a case specific basis; therefore, you should not rely on the general information on this site as a substitute for proper legal research or the advice of a licenced lawyer.